2017 All-Stars
Girls
| Wells, Trinity | 8 | Newark |
| Rice Porter, Chance | 8 | Waterloo |
| Reisch, Roxana | 10 | Harley-Allen |
| Behrendt, Adriana | 10 | Wayne Central |
| Gullace, Mikayla | 12 | Honeoye Central |
| Page, Courtney | 12 | Waterloo |
| Corey, Riley | 11 | Waterloo |
| Cotter, Mary | 8 | Harley-Allen |
| Murphy, Gracie | 9 | Penn Yan |
| Spencer, Olivia | 12 | Red Jacket |
| Doyle, Jaina | 9 | Penn Yan |
| Sheffield, Sunniva | 12 | Harley-Allen |
| Cotter, Liza | 10 | Harley-Allen |
| Erwin, Ellie | 9 | Williamson |
| Sawyer, Alison | 9 | Red Creek |
| Burrall, Audra | 11 | Geneva |
| Carbajal, Samantha | 11 | Sodus Central |
| Bedell, Skylar | 10 | Geneva |
| Browning, Lauren | 12 | Harley-Allen |
| Vella, Middy | 9 | Harley-Allen |
| Fiorini, Emma | 12 | Harley-Allen |
| Shangraw, Haley | 11 | Waterloo |
| Rath, Emma | 10 | Clyde-Savannah |
| Gillette, Audrey | 9 | Honeoye Central |
| Turner, Sennett | 10 | Waterloo |
| Aliperti, Ellie | 11 | Geneva |
| Schultz, Ryan | 11 | Geneva |
| Burgey, Madison | 9 | Geneva |
| Adams, Aaliyah | 10 | Mynderse |
| Dunstan, Alaska | 9 | Wayne Central |
Boys
| Vandermortel, Dillon | 12 | Newark |
| Stash, Gabe | 12 | Marcus Whitman |
| Dietschler, Ethan | 12 | Clyde-Savannah |
| Bathgate, Gavin | 10 | East Rochester |
| Carnicelli, Jeremiah | 12 | Mynderse |
| Brignall, Hunter | 11 | Mynderse |
| Royston, Aiden | 9 | Marcus Whitman |
| Prendergast, Liam | 10 | Marcus Whitman |
| Frisbee, Daniel | 12 | Waterloo |
| DeMoras, Ben | 12 | Penn Yan |
| Vivlamore, Aaron | 11 | Red Creek |
| Hallett, James | 10 | Honeoye Central |
| Eighmey, Noah | 11 | Geneva |
| Eckler, Ben | 12 | Palmyra-Macedon |
| Jones, Tyler | 12 | Williamson Central |
| Lyons, Alex | 11 | Marcus Whitman |
| Manley, Brandon | 12 | NRW |
| Brewington, Mack | 9 | Marion |
| Page, Nick | 11 | Waterloo |
| Atwater, Sam | 12 | Clyde-Savannah |
| McHugh, Max | 10 | Red Jacket |
| Surkau-Parkinson, Connor | 12 | HAC |
| Taylor, Malakai | 11 | Mynderse |
| Mowry, Ayden | 9 | Penn Yan |
| Haltiner, Broden | 8 | Newark |
| Kellogg, Liam | 12 | Newark |
| Wilson, Garrett | 9 | HAC |
| Louden, Henry | 10 | Geneva |
| French, Kyle | 11 | Newark |
| Ventura, Giovanni | 11 | Geneva |
